DIY Homemade Dog Treats to Keep Your Pup Happy and Healthy

Do you ever worry about what, exactly, your dog is eating when you feed them store-bought dog treats? End your worries by making your own homemade dog treats. It’s easier than it sounds.

While dog food and treats are specifically made for dogs, many dogs are allergic to one or more of the ingredients used. Allergic reactions can vary from rashes to hives. Making your own treats lets you leave out any ingredients that may cause an uncomfortable allergic reaction in your dog.

With these recipes, YOU control the ingredients your dog digests. All of the ingredients are puppy-approved for safety and yumminess. But first of all, make sure to check out our article on 50+ Human Food Your Dogs Can And Can Not Eat to avoid feeding your dog anything unhealthy for their health!

Best Homemade Dog Treat Recipes

1. Pumpkin Peanut Butter Treats With Bacon Glaze

1. Pumpkin Peanut Butter Treats With Bacon Glaze

Pinch of Yum’s pumpkin peanut butter homemade dog treats combines two of dogs’ favorite people foods. The bacon glaze is made with bacon grease, but some owners may prefer to use coconut oil or another oil.

Be sure, of course, to use a peanut butter that doesn’t contain xylitol, which is fatal for dogs.

Full Recipe on Pinch of Yum

2. Chicken and Wild Rice Dog Biscuits

2. Chicken and Wild Rice Dog Biscuits

Carrie’s Experimental Kitchen recipe utilizes natural ingredients, such as chicken and rice, for a healthy AND tasty treat for Fido. You can use leftover chicken to whip up these health-conscious treats.

Chicken and rice are easy on a dog’s stomach, making these treats perfect for those pups with sensitive tummies.

Full Recipe on Carrie’s Experimental Kitchen

3. Heart-shaped Cranberry Cookies

3. Heart-shaped Cranberry Cookies

Everyday Dog Mom has a Valentine’s recipe for all the other dog moms out there. Cranberries are safe for dogs to eat, but your pooch may not like the tart flavor. We suggest giving your dog a plain cranberry first.

The heart-shaped cookie cutters can be found at any online retailer.

Full Recipe on Everyday Dog Mom

4. Watermelon Pupsicles

4. Watermelon Pupsicles

Many dogs come running at the sound of a refrigerator’s ice machine. The cool, refreshing taste of water is irresistible to dogs. Why not make it more flavorful by adding watermelon to the mix?

Grrfeisty recommends using seedless watermelons, as the seeds can disrupt a dog’s digestion. Use a blender to mix the ingredients before freezing in an ice cube tray.

Full Recipe on Grrfeisty

5. Peanut Butter and Pumpkin Homemade Dog Treat

5. Peanut Butter and Pumpkin Homemade Dog Treat

Mom On Timeout gives us another peanut butter and pumpkin homemade dog treat recipe. This one, however, doesn’t have a drizzle on top. The ingredients mention using pumpkin pie spice. However, spices, particularly nutmeg, are bad for dogs.

When making these treats, forego the spices. Your dog won’t miss them.

Full Recipe on Mom On Timeout

6. Sweet Potato Fries

6. Sweet Potato Fries

Sweet potatoes fries are one of the healthiest foods for people. They are also surprisingly healthy for your pup, too. The Beagles & Bargains recipe calls for cinnamon, which is okay for dogs in small amounts.

The website also lists other safe spices that can be used instead of, or in addition to, cinnamon.

Full Recipe on Beagles & Bargains

7. Crunchy Peanut Butter Treats

7. Crunchy Peanut Butter Treats

Peanut butter is very popular with dogs! This peanut butter recipe from The Cookie Rookie includes honey and natural peanut butter. As always, check the ingredients before using peanut butter. Many brands are now using the artificial sweetener, Xylitol.

The website notes that some dogs are allergic to wheat flour. They suggest rice flour as a substitute.

Full Recipe on The Cookie Rookie

8. Peanut Butter and Oats Homemade Dog Treat

8. Peanut Butter and Oats Homemade Dog Treat

More peanut butter homemade dog treats, but this time with a twist. Love From The Oven suggests using oats for a flavorful crunch to your homemade dog treats. This quick recipe can be made in 30 minutes, from start to finish.

The tasty treats only have 1 gram of fat for those pups on diets.

Full Recipe on Love From The Oven

9. Peanut Butter and Milk Homemade Dog Treats

9. Peanut Butter and Milk Homemade Dog Treats

While many other peanut butter recipes use oil, Life Family & Fun’s recipe uses milk. You can use cow milk, almond milk or any milk without artificial sweeteners.

The recipe also calls for molasses, making it a perfect treat for fall. Be sure to use peanut butter that’s safe for dogs.

Full Recipe on Life, Family, and Fun

10. Peanut Butter Banana Homemade Dog Treats

10. Peanut Butter Banana Homemade Dog Treats

In addition to peanut butter, dogs also go bananas for bananas. This simple recipe from Flora & Vino has just three ingredients. Along with peanut butter and bananas, oats are used to give the treats a nice crunch.

The website advises bakers to watch the treats closely, as they can easily burn in the oven. Your dog would probably eat them anyway.

Full Recipe on Flora & Vino

11. Healthy Pumpkin and Peanut Butter Homemade Dog Treats

11. Healthy Pumpkin and Peanut Butter Homemade Dog Treats

101 Cooking For Two touts this recipe as a low-calorie homemade dog treat. Using pumpkin and peanut butter dough, the recipe doesn’t need fancy cooking cutters.

However, the site advises dog owners not to use “low-calorie” brands of peanut butter because they often contain the toxic ingredient xylitol.

Full Recipe on 101 Cooking For Two

12. Yogurt and Berry Homemade Dog Treats

12. Yogurt and Berry Homemade Dog Treats

Gemma’s Bigger Bolder Baking has a peanut butter dog treat recipe. However, what caught our eye – and our dogs’ taste buds – is the yogurt and berry treat. The recipe calls for a mix of plain yogurt and dog-friendly berries.

The website recommends strawberries and blueberries for this tasty treat.

Full Recipe on Bigger Bolder Baking

13. Homemade Peanut Butter Dog Treats

13. Homemade Peanut Butter Dog Treats

This all-natural peanut butter recipe is simple and delicious. Your pup will enjoy the tasty, yet healthy treat. Chica and Jo recommend using all-natural peanut butter with just peanut butter and salt for ingredients, nothing else.

Your dog will be able to enjoy these treats twenty minutes or so.

Full Recipe on Chica and Jo

14. Peanut Butter and Coconut Oil Homemade Dog Treats

14. Peanut Butter and Coconut Oil Homemade Dog Treats

Live Laugh Rowe brings us peanut butter dog treats mixed with coconut oil. As you may know, coconut oil has many health benefits for dogs, including a shiny coat. The recipe suggests unprocessed coconut oil.

Rather than a cookie cutter, they use a paw print tray that can easily be found online.

Full Recipe on Live Laugh Rowe

Do You Have a Homemade Dog Treat Recipe to Share?

Homemade dog treats are a simple way to provide your dog with healthier treats. We’ve provided the best homemade dog treat recipes for now, but we’re always on the lookout for more.

If you have a homemade dog treat recipe you’d like to share, contact us at Leo(@)cyberpet.com. In the meantime, use one of the above recipes to make your dog a tasty treat.

1 thought on “DIY Homemade Dog Treats to Keep Your Pup Happy and Healthy”

Leave a Comment