Have you ever found yourself out on a walk with your dog only to realize just a moment too late that you are out of doggie poop bags? Nothing makes you feel more like a lousy dog owner than leaving a steaming pile behind on the trail.
With a full supply of poop bags on hand, you can easily avoid this embarrassing situation. But with so many options, how do you choose the best poop bag for you and your dog.
There are large ones, small ones, biodegradable ones, ones with ties, and ones in every color imaginable. When did dog waste bags get so complicated?!
Lucky for you, it doesn’t have to be that complex. We’ve scoured the market for the best dog poop bags of every variety and listed them here to make your job of ordering poop bags stink just a less.
The Best Dog Poop Bags
- Best Overall: UNNI 100% Compostable Bag
- Best Value: AmazonBasics Dog Waste Bag
- Best Flushable: Flush Puppies Flushable Bag
- For Large Dogs: Planet Poop Large Bag
UNNI 100% Compostable Bag
AmazonBasics Dog Waste Bag
Flush Puppies Flushable Bag
Planet Poop Large Bag
Reviews of The Best Dog Poop Bags
#1. UNNI 100% Compostable Bag
Best Overall
Compostable
Biodegradable
Polyurethane free
Pricier than plastic
No dog poop bag holder
No handles
The first product on our list combines the easy use of a typical plastic poop bag with the earth-friendly innovation of a plant-based product. UNNI’s 100% compostable dog poop bags will save you the mess while saving the planet.
These ingenious little bags are polyethylene free which means they don’t require oil to be manufactured. They are made with renewable plant starches instead.
Compostable dog poop bags such as these can be disposed of in your municipal compost or thrown away with your normal trash. The unfortunate thing about biodegradable dog poop bags is they must be exposed to oxygen to degrade correctly, which isn’t often the case in landfills.
These bags are standard size (9” by 13”) and perfect for the average-sized dog (and the average-sized doody). And they come in packs of 120 with 15 bags per roll.
These bags will fit in any standard poop bag roll dispenser and feel a little thicker than most plastic bags. They will cost you more than bags containing synthetic ingredients but are worth the extra investment to do your part for the planet.
#2. AmazonBasics Dog Waste Bag
Best Value
Available in bulk
Cheap
EPI additive optional
Made of polyurethane
No handles
Second on our list, are poop bags made especially for owners living in apartments and other situations that require them to pick up after their dog with bags frequently. AmazonBasics Dog Waste Bags are available in huge quantities and even come with an optional feature for the environmentally conscious.
These bags come in both the standard black plastic variety as well as an EPI additive green variety. The EPI bags are still made with polyurethane but contain an additive that helps the bag break down faster than plastic alone.
When it comes to cheap dog poop bags, you won’t find a better deal than this. The plastic-type come in packs up to 900 for about the same price as our number one pick which only includes 120.
The EPI bags are about the same price for 810 bags.
Both bag types are standard size and come in rolls of 15. They will also fit in a standard size holder, but as a bonus, these bags come with a simple plastic roll dispenser.
If you’re looking for the best dog poop bags bulk pricing, and the added option to help the planet, this is the brand to go with.
#3. Flush Puppies Flushable Bag
Best Flushable
Flushable
Compostable
Thicker than standard bags
Expensive
Don’t fit in roll dispensers
Fewer bags per order
If you’re looking for the most earth-friendly way to dispose of your dog’s poop, you’ve found it with our number three pick. Flush Puppies flushable dog poop bags not only make clean up a breeze but help keep unnecessary waste out of our overtaxed landfills.
Flush Puppies are made from polyvinyl alcohol, a synthetic polymer that is water-soluble. While this product is not made from natural starches like our number one choice, it is non-toxic and safe to flush down the toilet.
Not only are you helping the planet by keeping waste out of the trash with these bags, but you’re also reducing the risk for disease contamination. Poop disposed of in the trash can leach diseases into the soil and groundwater and cause other animals and humans to get sick.
But by flushing your dog’s poop, it will be safely cleaned with human waste at water treatment plants.
These bags are standard-sized but come in flat “wallet” packs instead of traditional rolls. They will not fit into a roll dispenser but are easily carried in a pocket or treat bag.
They come in orders of 60 with 20 bags in each pack. They cost slightly less than the others on our list per order but are more expensive per bag.
#4. Planet Poop Large Bag
For Large Dogs
100% plant material
Compostable and biodegradable
Extra large with handles
Fewer bags per roll
More expensive
The last bags on our list were made especially for owners of large dogs. Planet Poop’s large-sized poop bags are longer than standard bags and have handles for easy tying.
Dog poop bags with handles are necessary when you have a dog with a unique talent for making a mess, or just a giant breed that leaves giant deposits. Fold the handles back as you pick up the mess to keep them clean and then use them to quickly and cleanly secure the load.
These bags are also three inches longer than most bags and thicker, meaning they can handle even the heaviest of messes.
Another great feature of these bags is that they are fully biodegradable, compostable and made from 100% plant material. They contain no polyurethane or other harmful additives.
Like our number one pick, these bags can be disposed of in municipal compost or tossed with normal trash.
Each order contains 120 bags and costs a little more than our first choice pick. Each roll only contains 12 bags, but these do fit nicely on a standard roll dispenser.
What to Consider Before Choosing Poop Bags for Your Dog
It may seem a little silly to spend time considering the different features of something that’s just going to end up in the trash minutes after use, but finding the right poop bag for you can be the difference between a literal mess and a pleasant outing with the pooch.
Here are some different features to consider with different dog poop bag brands:
- Compostable/Biodegradable
- Handles
- Included dog poop bag dispenser
- Large vs. small
- Rolled vs. loose
- Colors and patterns
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Best Dog Poop Bag?
After reviewing a number of dog poop bags made of different materials, available in different sizes, and of all colors in the rainbow, we selected UNNI’s 100% Compostable Poop Bags as the best dog poop bag on the market.
These bags are better for the planet because they are made from plants and contain no polyurethane, and they can be composted in municipal composts. Like all bags on our list, they are thick and durable to keep the mess in the bag and off your hand.
If you are looking for a bag with other great features like flushability or handles, we’ve included options for those on our list as well.
